CrawlSpider vs AthenaHQ (2026): an honest comparison

Disclosure: I build CrawlSpider. So read this knowing I'm biased. I've tried to compare it with AthenaHQ the way I'd want a vendor to do it for me: where AthenaHQ is the better pick, I say so.

TL;DR

If you want a tool that tells you what to write and helps write it, AthenaHQ goes further than CrawlSpider. If you want clean daily measurement and you'll do the content work yourself, CrawlSpider costs about a fifteenth as much.

  • Choose AthenaHQ if you want content recommendations and an agent to help write the fix.
  • Choose CrawlSpider if you want clean daily measurement at a flat, predictable price.
CrawlSpider and AthenaHQ side by side
CrawlSpider mineAthenaHQ
Starting price$19/mo (Search Console dashboard free for 1 site)Free tier; $295/mo paid
Prompts on the entry plan15 (50 on $49, 100 on $99, more on request)Credit-based (3,600 credits)
AI assistants on the entry plan4: ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini, Perplexity8+ on paid plans
ClaudeIncluded on every planIncluded on paid plans
Google AI Overviews / AI ModeNoYes
Brands on the entry plan3 (10 on $49, 30 on $99)Not confirmed
Tracking frequencyDailyYour choice (uses credits)
Site audits or AI-crawler analyticsNoContent and on-page actions
Google Search Console reportingIncluded: multi-site dashboard, keyword and page opportunities, weekly emailGSC and GA4 connections, per reviewers
Shareable public dashboardYes, plus embeddable badge and PDF exportNot confirmed
Free way to tryFree AI snapshot, no signup; free Search Console dashboardFree Essential tier

What AthenaHQ is

AthenaHQ is an action-oriented GEO platform: monitoring across 8+ engines including Claude, plus a content optimization agent and recommendations. There's a free Essential tier; paid plans are credit-based, and the most advanced features (its citation engine, advanced content agents) are on Enterprise.

What CrawlSpider is

CrawlSpider puts two things in one subscription: AI visibility tracking and Google Search Console reporting. It runs your buyer questions through ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity every day and shows where your brand is mentioned, where a competitor is mentioned instead, and how the answer describes you. The same plan connects your Google Search Console and turns it into a multi-site dashboard with keyword opportunities, page opportunities (content decay, low CTR, cannibalization and more), 16 months of history and a weekly email per site. Every paid plan includes all four assistants, competitor mention share, sentiment, citation tracking and a shareable public dashboard, and prompt volume scales beyond the listed plans on request. It does not track Google AI Overviews, AI Mode or Copilot as AI answers, and it doesn't audit your pages.

Where AthenaHQ is better

  • Help acting on the data. A content optimization agent and recommendations. CrawlSpider shows you missed questions and leaves the fix to you.
  • More engines. 8+ on paid plans, including Google's AI surfaces, Copilot and Grok.
  • A free tier for ongoing light use.

Where CrawlSpider is better

  • Price. $19 vs $295.
  • Predictable billing. AthenaHQ reviewers report burning a month's credits in the first week. CrawlSpider has fixed prompts, run daily.
  • Multiple brands on cheap plans for agencies and portfolio owners.
  • Search Console reporting at $19. AthenaHQ connects Search Console to attribute AI impact on a $295 plan. CrawlSpider includes a Search Console report for every site in your plan, with keyword and page opportunities, and the dashboard is free for one site.

Pricing

CrawlSpider
$19/month for 15 prompts and 3 sites; $49 for 50 prompts and 10 sites; $99 for 100 prompts and 30 sites; larger prompt volumes on request. Every paid plan includes Search Console reporting for the same sites, and the Search Console dashboard is free for one site. All four assistants on every paid plan, billed monthly.
AthenaHQ
Free Essential tier (300 credits); Self-Serve $295/month for 3,600 credits; Enterprise custom.

How to decide

If you're unsure, run CrawlSpider's free snapshot and AthenaHQ's trial or free option on the same ten questions. You'll learn more from that than from any comparison page, including this one.

Questions

Is AthenaHQ free?

There's a free Essential tier with 300 credits. Paid self-serve starts at $295 a month.

Does AthenaHQ track Claude?

Yes, on paid plans. So does CrawlSpider, on every plan from $19.

What does a credit buy on AthenaHQ?

Roughly one AI response per credit, per reviewers. Prompts times engines times frequency adds up fast, so model it before you buy.

Try CrawlSpider

Enter your website and get a free snapshot of where ChatGPT, Claude, Gemini and Perplexity mention you and who they mention instead. No signup, no credit card. If it's useful, daily tracking starts at $19 a month, with your Google Search Console reporting included in the same plan.

Find my visibility gaps

I checked prices and features for every tool here in late September to mid-October 2026, using vendor pricing pages and recent independent reviews. Pricing in this category changes often, sometimes monthly, so confirm on the vendor's site before you buy. If something here is wrong, tell me and I'll fix it.

More guides

Head-to-head comparisons

Alternatives